Google
 
Web www.howardforums.com
Pages: 1

I love SE but whats the deal?

(Click here to view the original thread with full colors/images)


Posted by: gw21

Why doesn't SE already have this? Nokia has had something closer for a while now.

I need a quadband phone without touch screen and would like it to have these features in no particular order...

Candy bar
Above average 2-3 Mp camera w/flash
Wifi
Fm Radio w/transmitter
Above average Mp3 player
3.5mm jack

I'm still using a T637 some that I've had for 4 yrs. so I don't change phones very often. I like SE's for the battery life. The W960 is almost the perfect phone for me, but no quadband. The C702 would almost be, but no Wifi.

Why do they think there are people that listen to music or take pictures or web surf almost exclusively? Is there no demand for a "do it all" phone with SE users?

I want a new phone and would like it to be a SE but they won't make it. Nokia has had a couple of phones that fit this category all except the FM transmitter which is going to be on the N78. I hate to turn my back on SE but the N78 looks very attractive.


Your thoughts are welcome.



Posted by: newtype2011

I'm right here with you. I Personally use more Nokia devices than SE, but I will always have a soft spot for their products. If they would make a quadband device with wifi, at least the k790a's camera, and a 3.5mm jack, they would have an absolute killer device on their hands...but they won't for some reason, so we are stuck with "blah" device after "blah" device. Many thought that the K850 would be the savior, but its (very) poor camera quality and software problems have kept it from carrying the torch. Many die-hard SE fans still use a K800 variant or a w810 because, IMO, those are the two last great phones that SE made...they have just dropped off in making good phones over the past year.

They need to get back on track. Nokia is already ahead of the pack in terms of hardware features, but SE seems to just be widening the gap with its own lack of innovation...

...that is, until the X1 is released -



Posted by: ThorBlaze Dragon

the rumored P5 may fit your need, but I doubt it exists
you need to step down abit to get C702, which has GPS
I'm gonna get X1, but the price...



Posted by: RLP06

If they made a device like that, no one would buy Sony Mp3 players or Sony Cameras.... they gotta think about their other divisions....

Do you not think SE has thought of making the perfect device? Of course they have... are they ever? NO

Nokia N82 is pretty damn close to being the perfect phone, except its ugly



Posted by: newtype2011

Quote:
Originally Posted by RLP06
If they made a device like that, no one would buy Sony Mp3 players or Sony Cameras.... they gotta think about their other divisions....

Do you not think SE has thought of making the perfect device? Of course they have... are they ever? NO



I personally don't agree with you: there is a FAR higher margin selling a phone vs an mp3 player or camera. Also, according to what you said, they wouldn't have released ANY walkman phones at all because they would be worried that it would eat away at their own mp3 business...which is losing the battle to apple on a daily/monthly/yearly basis. I would push full force in the mobile industry where I have some market share, credibility, and name recognition...none of which I have in the dap market anymore.

If I were Sony, I would consider putting more resources behind a product that has more potential for sales and profit. And their mobile division is turning a profit - - and I guess they are content with how much that is pulling in because they certainly aren't stretching themselves to do better or make any waves (X1 aside, of course).



Posted by: ThorBlaze Dragon

Quote:
Originally Posted by RLP06
If they made a device like that, no one would buy Sony Mp3 players or Sony Cameras.... they gotta think about their other divisions....

Do you not think SE has thought of making the perfect device? Of course they have... are they ever? NO

Nokia N82 is pretty damn close to being the perfect phone, except its ugly


this is a complete BS
currently I use HP211 as audio player, it has removable 48GB solid state storage and native wireless headphones support, and I have Canon A620 cam



Posted by: MP

Someday they will play a little catch up.. Looks like they let nokia "test" the waters b4 they get fancy with anything. I keep thinking about jumping ship if the n82 ever gets us 3g. Its almost the perfect device for what I do. (ya I know it is ugly most nokia's are a little plain on the looks)


A better question would be when the hell are they going to make a battery door that wont creak and click. Maybe they should include a piece of a matchbook in the box as a shim.



Posted by: Phone Diva

N81 and N96 look good for Nokias though, LOL! The N81 is the best looking Nokia I ever owned. Too bad the camera looks like it'll suck real bad, LOL!



Posted by: bigb252

Yea, I'm actually jumping ship to an N82 from Amazon by the end of this month. I waited too long for AT&T to release the K850, and for those that bought it outright, most just say it wasn't worth the $400+ price tag. Plus I get WiFi.

Be sure that I will get one of the new C or G series models. The x1 is really cool, but the price tag will chase me away until probably 6 months after its released. I might as well wait for the x2?



Posted by: marktang

alot of nokia looks really good on paper but when u actually use it that's another story. in my opinion both companies are targeting different customers. so u cant really say who's better and who isnt. like Nokia they try to pack everything in their phones but the battery life sucks so whats the point of having so many functions if your battery cant even last that long.
SE is targeting more the average buyers. who might just need a camera or just a mp3.



Posted by: RLP06

Quote:
Originally Posted by marktang
alot of nokia looks really good on paper but when u actually use it that's another story. in my opinion both companies are targeting different customers. so u cant really say who's better and who isnt. like Nokia they try to pack everything in their phones but the battery life sucks so whats the point of having so many functions if your battery cant even last that long.
SE is targeting more the average buyers. who might just need a camera or just a mp3.


If they just stuck a xenon flash and 850band on a P1i, it'd be the perfect device



Posted by: MP

Quote:
Originally Posted by RLP06
If they just stuck a xenon flash and 850band on a P1i, it'd be the perfect device



you notice the lack of 850 much?



Posted by: Phone Diva

Quote:
Originally Posted by marktang
alot of nokia looks really good on paper but when u actually use it that's another story. in my opinion both companies are targeting different customers. so u cant really say who's better and who isnt. like Nokia they try to pack everything in their phones but the battery life sucks so whats the point of having so many functions if your battery cant even last that long.
SE is targeting more the average buyers. who might just need a camera or just a mp3.


I've gotten EXCELLENT battery life on S60 phones. Although I never do a whole lot of things at once, so maybe that's why.



Posted by: newtype2011

Quote:
Originally Posted by marktang
alot of nokia looks really good on paper but when u actually use it that's another story. in my opinion both companies are targeting different customers. so u cant really say who's better and who isnt. like Nokia they try to pack everything in their phones but the battery life sucks so whats the point of having so many functions if your battery cant even last that long.
SE is targeting more the average buyers. who might just need a camera or just a mp3.


I get excellent battery life on my N95-3 if (and only if) I turn off the 3G. The N82 gets better battery life than most other phones, especially phones that have similar features. Oh wait, no phones have similar features that come in that size. Also, their N82 is probably their most mainstream device that has wi-fi and a great camera.

SE is only targeting the mid-price market...I don't think they are targeting any consumer in particular. They say that are trying to sell to people who want their music on the go, yet, they offer no devices with a 3.5mm jack or a high quality OEM adaptor for your own headphones. That's crap. I was really excited with SE's potential after phones like the w810 and K800 series, but they just haven't released anything that truly warrants a purchase. I want an SE pretty bad, but I don't want to plunk down money for a 2 year old phone from them. Times are changing. People want things in their phones that SE is not willing to offer.

This is purely my opinion and I may get flamed for it, but I see ZERO reason to buy any of the newer SEs for other than their far cheaper price. Zero. Too many companies are offering too many things that SEs are just falling behind in.

Having said that, the W980 looks like a really cool phone, but I just couldn't justify spending more than $400 on it since it doesn't have wifi, af cam or a 3.5mm jack. I don't even like the N82 very much but I would rather have that for only $100 more.



Posted by: Phone Diva

Tri-band 3G and design is my reason, but wifi is LONG overdue!

On Walkman phones, they need a standard jack. Adapters are a pain!



Posted by: marktang

oh i know alot of ppl have bad experiences with battery life in the Nseries, myself included. i use the phone alot and i cant get 1 day out of the battery even with N95 8GB. even my tytn II and cruise gets at least 2 days.



Posted by: Phone Diva

Well the N81 8GB works fine for me. So did the E61 and E70-A.

I didn't use the N95 yet, nor the popular N82, so I don't know about those firsthand.



Posted by: escapevelocity

Quote:
Originally Posted by Fire Dragan 418
I'm gonna get X1, but the price...


ditto...

what's the price range, btw?



Posted by: marktang

from my experience in phones i think it will settle at around 800cdn.



Posted by: newtype2011

Quote:
Originally Posted by marktang
oh i know alot of ppl have bad experiences with battery life in the Nseries, myself included. i use the phone alot and i cant get 1 day out of the battery even with N95 8GB. even my tytn II and cruise gets at least 2 days.


I won't disagree with you here. Many SE phones usually have 7-9 hour talk times and extremely long stand-by times...but that's just the thing...if your spend the majority of the time using your phone for calls and texts only, of course the battery will last forever. I'd rather have a mini-computer in my pocket that is with me at all times than a device that is running on 2 year old technology. And in reality, most people don't restrict their device use just because the battery will run out in a day.

I will be the FIRST person to pick up a quadband SE that has wifi, af cam, and 3.5mm jack that runs on the A200 platform. That would be a sweet device. The X1 is cool, but I would like to see some mid-range SE phones (price-wise) with similar features -



Posted by: MP

Wirelessly posted (Fone: SonyEricssonK790a/R8BC Browser/NetFront/3.3 Profile/MIDP-2.0 Configuration/CLDC-1.1 UP.Link/6.3.1.20.0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by newtype2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by marktang
oh i know alot of ppl have bad experiences with battery life in the Nseries, myself included. i use the phone alot and i cant get 1 day out of the battery even with N95 8GB. even my tytn II and cruise gets at least 2 days.


I won't disagree with you here. Many SE phones usually have 7-9 hour talk times and extremely long stand-by times...but that's just the thing...if your spend the majority of the time using your phone for calls and texts only, of course the battery will last forever. I'd rather have a mini-computer in my pocket that is with me at all times than a device that is running on 2 year old technology. And in reality, most people don't restrict their device use just because the battery will run out in a day.

I will be the FIRST person to pick up a quadband SE that has wifi, af cam, and 3.5mm jack that runs on the A200 platform. That would be a sweet device. The X1 is cool, but I would like to see some mid-range SE phones (price-wise) with similar features -


As everyone else would agree. A device with that stuff for 350-450 would sell like no ones business (watch the N82 in the next few-its the nokia version of what we want for 600 bucks). Or they can pump out 3 phones that each have 2 of those features and sell lots more phones to the same people. It sucks. They know there markets and how to work them.



Posted by: newtype2011

Quote:
Originally Posted by Matts_k790a
Wirelessly posted (Fone: SonyEricssonK790a/R8BC Browser/NetFront/3.3 Profile/MIDP-2.0 Configuration/CLDC-1.1 UP.Link/6.3.1.20.0)



As everyone else would agree. A device with that stuff for 350-450 would sell like no ones business (watch the N82 in the next few-its the nokia version of what we want for 600 bucks). Or they can pump out 3 phones that each have 2 of those features and sell lots more phones to the same people. It sucks. They know there markets and how to work them.


I agree. And I'm afraid they will do this for some time to come. If anything, it's just annoying. Also, they have ZERO phones that have a 3.5mm jack or are quadband with wifi. ZERO. That shows their dedication to the high-end market.

Oh, and:

You can get an American N82 (with US warranty, not US 3G) from Amazon for $499...that is a pretty good deal IMO for a phone that has wifi and one the best cameras on the market. How can SE charge $499 for the K850 when it is sorely lacking in so many ways compared to the N82?

What's the deal? I would just love to sit down with their CEO (or whoever else is in charge of what phones they release) and ask why they refuse to pump out good phones.



Posted by: MP

I think theres a n82 coming out with us 3g soon.



Posted by: Phone Diva

Do you have a link? I'd love to see that!!

I saw that it's coming on the US Nokia site, but that might be the same 2100 version.



Posted by: MP

dont remember where it was, but i saw it. If I find it Ill pass it along.



Posted by: newtype2011

I really don't see this phone coming out with 3G any time soon. There is a new black color planned, but it is unlikely that they will change the hardware specs. It is considered a "high-end" mid-level Nseries, so I don't see this getting the N95 treatment. I personally want them to give it a triband 3G chip, then this phone would be one of the greatest Nokia devices ever. K850 did it, the N82 should have.

And yes, the one coming to the Nokiausa site will be the Euro 3G one -



Posted by: MP

why wouldn't they go us 3g?

I would be really really temped to buy one.



Posted by: newtype2011

They aren't done milking the US market for the Euro version yet -_-



Posted by: Phone Diva

No Qualcomm is the reason. They are still in a legal fight with them, and Qualcomm makes the multi-band radio chips they'd need.

As of now, they use Broadcomm chips, which only seems to do dual band 3G chips at the most. That's probably the reason for different N95 versions.



Posted by: newtype2011

Quote:
Originally Posted by Phone Diva
No Qualcomm is the reason. They are still in a legal fight with them, and Qualcomm makes the multi-band radio chips they'd need.

As of now, they use Broadcomm chips, which only seems to do dual band 3G chips at the most. That's probably the reason for different N95 versions.


While 100% true, this does not explain why they don't release the US version until months after the phone is released elsewhere in the world. They can do it if they wanted to. Just look at the N78 - - there is a Euro version and a US version. Everyone wins.

- - - - -

I saw an interesting article today that reminded me of some of the things we were talking about with SE:

http://www.intomobile.com/2008/03/1...ales-slide.html

To be frank, I'm NOT shocked to see this at all. Maybe it will light a fire under them and give them the drive to produce some GREAT devices -



Posted by: Phone Diva

Because the mainstream US market still likes free or cheap carrier phones more. We're the exception here, not the rule. One good thing about the iPhone is once people break out of that cheap or free mode then we can make some progress, and both Sony and Nokia will make more effort in our market.

Also remember that US carrier restrictions slaughter phones. Perhaps they are not willing to let all their good phones get watered down.



Posted by: MP

our poor economy isnt going to help that at all..



Posted by: Phone Diva

Lets see how many Apple phones they sell the next quarter. If they still can sell those, there may be hope. People go into debt like crazy in this country when they really want something, even with a bad economy!



Posted by: newtype2011

Quote:
Originally Posted by Phone Diva
Because the mainstream US market still likes free or cheap carrier phones more. We're the exception here, not the rule. One good thing about the iPhone is once people break out of that cheap or free mode then we can make some progress, and both Sony and Nokia will make more effort in our market.


What does that have to do with Nokia or anyone making phones for the US market? If they have the audacity to bring the Euro phones here, tweak the FW, change the contents of the box, etc, than they should have the decency to make two versions of the phone. The ONLY reason I say this is because they release the Euro version here, only to release the "proper" phone several months later.

**They know that they will be releasing the US version soon, yet they still release the EXACT same phone here, minus the 3G band.** That is called milking the market for everything they can...they know many people who are currently buying their high-end devices may dump the euro versions and get the US 3G ones. Look at the N95-1 to the N95-3 exodus that happend....That is why I always urge everyone to wait at least 4-6 months to get ANY Nseries device released here...you may get burned if you don't.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Phone Diva
Also remember that US carrier restrictions slaughter phones. Perhaps they are not willing to let all their good phones get watered down.


This has nothing to do with why Nokia will not release two versions of the phone at the same time. Nokia quite easily sells the phones themselves. Not only that, they have totally branched out and are now offering them through MANY online retailers, some often being cheaper than Nokiausa themselves. I'd say 95% of the people here on Hofo did NOT buy their Nokia from Nokia directly. I don't work for Nokia so I obviously do not know what they are thinking, but from the outside looking in, it is all about money at the expense of our loyalty. They rush the phone to the US market, cash in, pull the euro phones, then release the version that should have come out in the first place. Just look to the N95-3 and N95-4 of examples. Those are the phones that SHOULD have come out here instead of the euro versions -



Posted by: MP

this **** has ben covered so many times.



Posted by: newtype2011

Quote:
Originally Posted by Matts_k790a
this **** has ben covered so many times.



...I had to beat the horse again to make my point



Posted by: MP

I know, but we all understand that everyone in the US just needs to buy better phones for us to get the "more better" phones.

If they cant make money here, they wont sell em here.



Posted by: Phone Diva

Quote:
Originally Posted by newtype2011
What does that have to do with Nokia or anyone making phones for the US market? There's not enough incentive to make high end US phones, is what I was trying to say. Due to many US buyers always wanting the cheapest or free phones.If they have the audacity to bring the Euro phones here, tweak the FW, change the contents of the box, etc, than they should have the decency to make two versions of the phone. The ONLY reason I say this is because they release the Euro version here, only to release the "proper" phone several months later.

**They know that they will be releasing the US version soon, yet they still release the EXACT same phone here, minus the 3G band.** That is called milking the market for everything they can...they know many people who are currently buying their high-end devices may dump the euro versions and get the US 3G ones. Look at the N95-1 to the N95-3 exodus that happend....That is why I always urge everyone to wait at least 4-6 months to get ANY Nseries device released here...you may get burned if you don't.




This has nothing to do with why Nokia will not release two versions of the phone at the same time. Well Nokia should be aware now that many Americans insist on getting subsidized phones through carriers. Often when Nokia agrees to this, the end products sucks. E62 is a shell of the E61 and people say much stuff was disabled on the branded N75. Perhaps Nokia doesn't want any more of that.Nokia quite easily sells the phones themselves. Not only that, they have totally branched out and are now offering them through MANY online retailers, some often being cheaper than Nokiausa themselves. I'd say 95% of the people here on Hofo did NOT buy their Nokia from Nokia directly. I don't work for Nokia so I obviously do not know what they are thinking, but from the outside looking in, it is all about money at the expense of our loyalty. They rush the phone to the US market, cash in, pull the euro phones, then release the version that should have come out in the first place. Just look to the N95-3 and N95-4 of examples. Those are the phones that SHOULD have come out here instead of the euro versions -


My thoughts in red, on your reply to my post.

I understand why you're cynical and I guess I should be too, but I think Nokia and Sony both have cold feet about the US market because we are like no other. They release the Euro versions first to see if there's even an interest in the phone here. They see what sticks, and then send out the US version. Maybe not the best way to do business here, but that's what I think anyway. It's speculation on my part since I don't know what their thinking process is either. Having said that, there's much love for the N82 so where's the US version, Nokia? LOL!



Posted by: newtype2011

Quote:
Originally Posted by Phone Diva
My thoughts in red, on your reply to my post.

I understand why you're cynical and I guess I should be too, but I think Nokia and Sony both have cold feet about the US market because we are like no other. They release the Euro versions first to see if there's even an interest in the phone here. They see what sticks, and then send out the US version. Maybe not the best way to do business here, but that's what I think anyway. It's speculation on my part since I don't know what their thinking process is either. Having said that, there's much love for the N82 so where's the US version, Nokia? LOL!


...Yeah. I think many, many people want some N82 US love. Let's hope they can deliver -



Posted by: marktang

or if North American used the same frequency as everyone else then we wont have a problem at all in the first place lol



Posted by: Moe3754

I have had the N95-8gig and two N81's and the N73 and now they are all gone ,I returned the last N81 yesterday and have ordered a W580i from sony style that should be here tomorrow,I cannot see putting out that kind of money for a phone that is so poorly made and the Nokia CS is a total joke,read the thread about it on the S60 forum and maybe you would not be so quick to run to Nokia,everyone that I have had,had problems and it was not worth the trouble,so they were returned to where I got them.You want Nokia with US Warranty then check out bestbuy.com unlocked phones they have many Nokia's all with US warranty,this came from Nokia USA about the warranty because my last N81 was purchased from them,plus you get a one year warranty from bestbuy also!!!
If you get one,just hope you do not have to have it fixed by PALCO,you should really read this thread before you jump ship to Nokia, http://www.howardforums.com/showthread.php?t=1322819



Posted by: Phone Diva

Quote:
Originally Posted by marktang
or if North American used the same frequency as everyone else then we wont have a problem at all in the first place lol


I don't get why there's the 1700 band. That one is so off it isn't even funny!!

I do wonder why NAM can't or won't use 2100, anyone know? I also hear the 2100 T-Mobile will use will be totally different from the 2100 we all know from Europe and Asia.



Posted by: Moe3754

T-mobile is 1700/2100 3G frequency,1700 transmit,2100 receive,it is the old Government frequency that they purchased last year!!!



Posted by: MP

has tmobile rolled out there 3g?

-- im a tmobile noob.



Posted by: expensive.taste

Quote:
Originally Posted by Moe3754
T-mobile is 1700/2100 3G frequency,1700 transmit,2100 receive,it is the old Government frequency that they purchased last year!!!



I know this maybe a dumb Q to some but what is the EDGE freq??? i am looking for a SE phone i can use EDGE on



Posted by: MP

Quote:
Originally Posted by expensive.taste
I know this maybe a dumb Q to some but what is the EDGE freq??? i am looking for a SE phone i can use EDGE on


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enhanc...r_GSM_Evolution

E850 here.



Posted by: expensive.taste

thanks!!! that helps alot



Posted by: Phone Diva

Quote:
Originally Posted by Moe3754
T-mobile is 1700/2100 3G frequency,1700 transmit,2100 receive,it is the old Government frequency that they purchased last year!!!


I heard that but what I meant was WHY would they buy a band that they don't have access to yet and that also seems to be non-standard? And why is the US 2100 different than the overseas one?



Posted by: Moe3754

I don't know ask them,but I do know that the 1700 frequency has better building penetration than the other 3g bands,why don't you go to this forum and ask there they are well versed in the t-mobile goings on more than I am http://www.cellphonesignal.com/t-mobile/ I am sure someone there could tell you all you wanted to know about it!!!As for having the band to use the 3G is said to be rolling out by late june or early july!!



Posted by: MP

carriers in the us are just to competitive. Even if 1700/2100 was open to all - some would still choose not to use it just to keep people on there network.
AND
now the 700Mhz auction... Oh god... Another odd ball freq?

Here we go again...





vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Limited.
vB Easy Archive Final ©2000 - 2008 - Created by Stefan "Xenon" Kaeser