receipt even says 8gb for 16gb and (100) in parenthesis. I guess that means credit.

Wanna pick some lotto numbers for me? |
Originally Posted by JBoogie
Every time something good happens to someone there is always a gloomy guss around to try to bring down your high..
![]() U lucked up nicely!! Wanna pick some lotto numbers for me? |
|
Originally Posted by hyoctane
So you post about the flop on a public forum? I don't think that's too swift... Not to mention unethical.
|
|
Originally Posted by hyoctane
Say you were at a local store... You go to purchase your items and give the cashier your money. S/he counts it, and gives you your change -- only s/he short-changed you by $100. Would you say "oh well, they messed up, lucky them."
Turn the tables and it doesn't sound too appealing anymore, huh? |
|
Originally Posted by 6820 tx
I went in to the apple store to exchange my 8gb for a another one (it had a defect) got home to unlock it and lo and behold it was a 16gb (no additional charge) by the way they didn't even turn my old phone on. She just asks me what was wrong and gave me a NEW one. I saw her unwrap the plastic and everything!! whew!!!
receipt even says 8gb for 16gb and (100) in parenthesis. I guess that means credit. |
|
Originally Posted by hyoctane
Say you were at a local store... You go to purchase your items and give the cashier your money. S/he counts it, and gives you your change -- only s/he short-changed you by $100. Would you say "oh well, they messed up, lucky them."
Turn the tables and it doesn't sound too appealing anymore, huh? |
|
Originally Posted by JBoogie
Every time something good happens to someone there is always a gloomy guss around to try to bring down your high..
![]() U lucked up nicely!! Wanna pick some lotto numbers for me? |
|
Originally Posted by Petey07
do they check to see if you have an active account with your sim card?
|
|
Originally Posted by hyoctane
Say you were at a local store... You go to purchase your items and give the cashier your money. S/he counts it, and gives you your change -- only s/he short-changed you by $100. Would you say "oh well, they messed up, lucky them."
Turn the tables and it doesn't sound too appealing anymore, huh? |
|
Originally Posted by hyoctane
So you post about the flop on a public forum? I don't think that's too swift... Not to mention unethical.
|
|
Originally Posted by hyoctane
So you post about the flop on a public forum? I don't think that's too swift... Not to mention unethical.
|
|
Originally Posted by hyoctane
So you post about the flop on a public forum? I don't think that's too swift... Not to mention unethical.
|
|
Originally Posted by hyoctane
So you post about the flop on a public forum? I don't think that's too swift... Not to mention unethical.
|
|
Originally Posted by hyoctane
I wasn't trying to piss on anyone's parade.
|
|
Originally Posted by hyoctane
Wow, I didn't expect to get flamed like that... I honestly am happy with my iPhone and if someone got an upgrade, rock on. I was just saying if it were me, I would have asked if it was correct in the midst of the checkout... No worries though as it seems like everyone hates me for my honesty now. I wasn't trying to piss on anyone's parade.
|
|
Originally Posted by cabinets
For what it's worth, I'm with you. As someone in their 40's, I get it. It makes no difference the size of the company, right is right and wrong is wrong. I guaranty most of the posters are children.
|
|
Originally Posted by Phreakish
I expect someone of your age to have better reading comprehension skills.
OP didn't cheat his way to a 16gb nor was the swap a mistake. He was given a 16gb with full intention of the Apple employee, hence his receipt. |
|
Originally Posted by cabinets
If his intentions were noble, he wouldn't have couched it using the terms he used. Had he been ethical, a simple question to the employee at Apple would have sufficed. If they said it was an inventory issue, then he was lucky. If the employee made a mistake, he/she is probably out of a job.
I would expect even the most juvenile of delinquents to understand this concept. |
|
Originally Posted by cabinets
For what it's worth, I'm with you. As someone in their 40's, I get it. It makes no difference the size of the company, right is right and wrong is wrong. I guaranty most of the posters are children.
|
|
Originally Posted by Aiku1337
You should rethink your argument. Age does not equal ethical. If that were the case then we wouldn't exactly have such stringent accounting practices for publicly held companies. Do you remember Enron?
|
|
Originally Posted by Aiku1337
You should rethink your argument. Age does not equal ethical. If that were the case then we wouldn't exactly have such stringent accounting practices for publicly held companies. Do you remember Enron?
|
|
Originally Posted by rockyjr
Everyone handles 'gift horses' in their own way. If it were me, yeah, I would have called the store and made sure things were right, but that's just me! If I am at a register and I see something ring up for less than the cost I tell the clerk. If s/he chooses to change the price, fine, if not, lucky me. I would do the same for being charged too much. For me, it has nothing to do with the size of the corporation or if it was a dumb mistake.
In this case, it would have been good for the clerk to say, "We are out of 8 gb models, so you are getting a credit toward a 16 gb upgrade." Or, "Our records indicate you paid more for this phone and didn't receive your 100 cash back. I can issue you a 100 dollar credit and put it toward a 16 gb phone." or any other adequate explanation to show that it was not an error on their part but the store's intention without an additional cost to the customer. Definitely, it would have been helpful for the clerk to clarify what was done. But, since she didn't, that's where this ethical war has come into play. And that's where the rubber meets the road--how does one handle this type of situation and does it go the same both ways? (Meaning, if original OP had gotten a 4 gb and a credit back for the difference on his credit card without being told, would he call the store and go back and get an 8 gb like he originally had?) IMO, that's what's really at battle here--and that's not why this thread was started. It was just so the OP could mention his windfall and share his experience at the Apple store. He didn't ask to be disected about how he handled it. |
|
Originally Posted by Aiku1337
There are so many unknowns here.
In any case. You're not supposed to look a gift horse in the mouth, right? ![]() |
|
Originally Posted by cabinets
Just a scientific wild *** guess...but my opinion is with age comes responsibility. Most people have heard of Enron, but if you question them on specifics, they would have no idea what transpired. But whatever, let them "get lucky", someone possibly lose their job, and the cost pass on to us.
|
|
Originally Posted by cabinets
Just a scientific wild *** guess...but my opinion is with age comes responsibility. Most people have heard of Enron, but if you question them on specifics, they would have no idea what transpired. But whatever, let them "get lucky", someone possibly lose their job, and the cost pass on to us.
|
|
Originally Posted by Phreakish
For someone your age you really aren't too bright.
I understand your argument and I agree with it; the size of the company doesn't make it more or less ethical to, as you've put it, "take money from them". However, this case has absolutely nothing to do with that ideology. The sheer fact that the OP's receipt reflects a credit towards the 16GB swap proves the direct intention of this transaction. People make mistakes by pressing the wrong key, typing the wrong code, etc. Giving out a more expensive device and giving credit towards the price difference is a mistake that's impossible to make. It takes effort. If people only read the posts they were replying to, we wouldn't have these idiotic discussions. |
|
Originally Posted by cabinets
So you're saying "taking" money/merchandise from a large company makes it ok, just not a small co.? What is your benchmark for this in revenue. I own a small business that generates about 6 million annually. Is it ok if one of my employees makes a mistake and the recipient of that mistake keeps their "good fortune"? Also, at most if not all banks(and many businesses), when there is a shortage at the end of the day, the employee is either fired or has to reimburse the dollars lost. I've seen that take place several times in the past few years with my bank. Also, my hunch is Apple might have given the 16gb due to no inventory(though they sent me home empty handed to wait on new refurbs for a swap). All I'm saying is there is no excuse to at least call when he got home. They may have said keep it. They may not have. Wouldn't you like to do what's right?
It's about character. Doing the right thing when no one is looking... |
|
Originally Posted by hyoctane
So you post about the flop on a public forum? I don't think that's too swift... Not to mention unethical.
|
vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2008,
Jelsoft Enterprises Limited.
vB Easy Archive Final ©2000 - 2008
- Created by Stefan "Xenon" Kaeser