Google
 
Web www.howardforums.com
Pages: 1

TomTom for iPhone!

(Click here to view the original thread with full colors/images)


Posted by: tks989

http://www.engadget.com/2008/06/09/...-ready-to-roll/

Quote:
That sound you hear is the not-yet-released nüvifone trembling in fear, as TomTom has just announced that an iPhone-ready version of its famed navigation software is practically ready to rock 'n roll. More specifically, a TomTom spokesman was quoted as saying that its "navigation system runs on the iPhone already," and he made the statement hot on the heels of the iPhone 3G announcement. Sadly, he wouldn't disclose an estimated release date for the software, but it's safe to say that the TomTom touch could make Apple's darling a formidable nüvifone opponent.


http://www.reuters.com/article/topN...B46553120080609

Quote:
AMSTERDAM (Reuters) - Dutch navigation device maker TomTom already has a version of its navigation software running on Apple's iPhone and has plans to sell it to consumers, a spokesman said on Monday.

"Our navigation system runs on the iPhone already," the TomTom spokesman said after Apple announced a new version of the iPhone that will include global positioning (GPS) capability.

The spokesman did not say when TomTom, Europe's biggest maker of car navigation devices, would be ready to start selling the software.




Posted by: tks989

maybe i might need that 16GB model. seems like a lot of high ranking companies are gonna wanna make great apps for it now. apple, is having everyone and anyone make apps so we can BUY them though.



Posted by: ivwshane

I wonder how much it will cost and if the maps will be stored locally?



Posted by: tks989

if this works fine on T-Mobile without needing 3G... thats all i need. i'll be happy!



Posted by: KDarling

Quote:
Originally Posted by ivwshane
I wonder how much it will cost and if the maps will be stored locally?


TomTom Navigator 6 for PDAs is around $150 on DVD. Yes, maps are locally stored. Less than 2GB, I think (could be wrong).

My big question is, does TomTom keep running even when a call comes in? Or does it exit as Apple wishes for most apps to do?



Posted by: Neo541

Quote:
Originally Posted by tks989
if this works fine on T-Mobile without needing 3G... thats all i need. i'll be happy!

I've been waiting for the iPhone to include GPS, but now that it does, I have a question.

Does anyone know if A-GPS instead of GPS would bar the iPhone from working on the T-Mobile network?



Posted by: californialifer

Hey didn't I read some were that tom tom was going to make a attachment for the first gen iphones so they could use gps ?



Posted by: ivwshane

Quote:
Originally Posted by KDarling
TomTom Navigator 6 for PDAs is around $150 on DVD. Yes, maps are locally stored. Less than 2GB, I think (could be wrong).

My big question is, does TomTom keep running even when a call comes in? Or does it exit as Apple wishes for most apps to do?


$150!!!!

I guess google maps is good enough! I was expecting $40. Besides maps what else do you get for $150?



Posted by: CA

Quote:
Originally Posted by ivwshane
$150!!!!

I guess google maps is good enough! I was expecting $40. Besides maps what else do you get for $150?
A lot!!!

1. Great UI! check link.
2. Map from exchange contacts
3. POIs,
4.Gas prices.
5. Much much better traffic...Google needs to do something here.
6. Map locally(when out of carrier coverage)

World of difference!

http://gizmodo.com/5014769/tomtom-h...-telenav-likely

Might even have voice input!



Posted by: cowboy1964

TomTom (and all the others I've seen) are way too overpriced. You can buy nice standalone GPS units for what they want to charge just for their software.

I expect some little guy to come out with a turn-by-turn app for the iPhone before too long. It shouldn't be that difficult. Google maps already gives you the directions, all we need is an app to turn that (no pun intended) into turn-by-turn steps.



Posted by: Goldenmonkey1

Quote:
Originally Posted by KDarling
TomTom Navigator 6 for PDAs is around $150 on DVD. Yes, maps are locally stored. Less than 2GB, I think (could be wrong).

My big question is, does TomTom keep running even when a call comes in? Or does it exit as Apple wishes for most apps to do?

USA map is 950MB. I use it on my treo 750



Posted by: samab

Quote:
Originally Posted by cowboy1964
TomTom (and all the others I've seen) are way too overpriced. You can buy nice standalone GPS units for what they want to charge just for their software.

I expect some little guy to come out with a turn-by-turn app for the iPhone before too long. It shouldn't be that difficult. Google maps already gives you the directions, all we need is an app to turn that (no pun intended) into turn-by-turn steps.


There is a reason why TomTom and Nokia are spending billions of dollars on buying up map companies.

Turn by turn navigation is pretty standard pricing for phones --- $3 a day or $10 a month. New companies getting into action will charge the same price.



Posted by: CA

Quote:
Originally Posted by cowboy1964
TomTom (and all the others I've seen) are way too overpriced. You can buy nice standalone GPS units for what they want to charge just for their software.

I expect some little guy to come out with a turn-by-turn app for the iPhone before too long. It shouldn't be that difficult. Google maps already gives you the directions, all we need is an app to turn that (no pun intended) into turn-by-turn steps.
Google maps mobile does have turn by turn kinda like 2D, but it is lacking in other areas.

Think about that one for a second. They all use either Navteq or TeleAtlas map data, and that's where the cost comes in. Yahoo, Google, and MapQuest also do, but they have larger licencing packages and in turn sell advertising.

Now that Tomtom is buying TeleAtlas and Nokia is buying Navteq it's going to get messy.

I'm betting on an iPhone version of the "Dash"! It uses GPRS data too.



Posted by: tks989

Quote:
Originally Posted by Neo541
I've been waiting for the iPhone to include GPS, but now that it does, I have a question.

Does anyone know if A-GPS instead of GPS would bar the iPhone from working on the T-Mobile network?


thats my question also. i don't like the sound of assisted gps



Posted by: SHoTTa35

Quote:
Originally Posted by tks989
thats my question also. i don't like the sound of assisted gps


Why wouldn't you? Assisted doesn't mean crippled like a assisting the lil old lady to cross the street. Assisted means it can get satalite information online instead of having the GPS chip search for the satalites to lock. If the chip knows where the satalites are/will be then it can lock faster.

aGPS is normal GPS with more features. Technology usually moves forward people



Posted by: klowngoblin

Quote:
Originally Posted by SHoTTa35
Technology usually moves forward people



in the case of the iphone.. not really.. but you said usually so i guess you covered your bases



Posted by: coolcellmunda

i cant wait for tom tom to come out on iPhone i personaly think it is the best gps software on any smartphones and i m looking forward to tomtom on iPhone



Posted by: ken.vs.ryu

should cost $150 or more. FTL.



Posted by: superlatives

Folks:

I would LOVE to see an iPhone version of Nokia Maps 2.0

Reason: Nokia Maps does something that no other (that I know of) navigation s/w does -- it gives you WALKING directions.

Here in Boston, Nokia Maps 2.0 even diagrams footpaths in Boston Common and the Public Garden. It also gives walking directions on streets which are one-way.



Posted by: Neo541

Quote:
Originally Posted by SHoTTa35
Why wouldn't you? Assisted doesn't mean crippled like a assisting the lil old lady to cross the street. Assisted means it can get satalite information online instead of having the GPS chip search for the satalites to lock. If the chip knows where the satalites are/will be then it can lock faster.

aGPS is normal GPS with more features. Technology usually moves forward people

Agreed, except our concern is about unlocked phones and using on another network. Where does the "assist" come from at that point? Or does it render the GPS useless if it tries to get the assist, and realizes it's not approved?



Posted by: superlatives

Quote:
Originally Posted by Neo541
Agreed, except our concern is about unlocked phones and using on another network. Where does the "assist" come from at that point? Or does it render the GPS useless if it tries to get the assist, and realizes it's not approved?

I don't know about the iPhone -- but on my Nokia N95 8GB, the GPS assist server is hosted by Nokia. AT&T merely provides the connection to Nokia's GPS assist server.

Whether the same will be true for the iPhone 3G, I don't know.



Posted by: KDarling

What we don't know yet, is if it is

1) Handset based aGPS -- Carrier server centers give assistance only in speeding up the first location lock. Phone GPS can also operate standalone.

or

2) Handset assisted aGPS --- (1), plus all calculations are done by the servers, not at the phone. Much cheaper handset.

Obviously handset based (1) is preferable.



Posted by: shawndh

Quote:
Originally Posted by KDarling
What we don't know yet, is if it is

1) Handset based aGPS -- Carrier server centers give assistance only in speeding up the first location lock. Phone GPS can also operate standalone.

or

2) Handset assisted aGPS --- (1), plus all calculations are done by the servers, not at the phone. Much cheaper handset.

Obviously handset based (1) is preferable.


I would hope it has real GPS and the assist is just to get a quicker lock on your location. That's how my phone works.



Posted by: jvanbrecht

TomTom pricing is $99 for the software only option, same as the Garmin software only option. That does not include the cost of the monthly service if you want traffic updates and other services.

As for the other issue..

AGPS is not really a step forward... Think of the old Winmodems (if you were around in the days of dialup. To make the modems cheaper, they made alot of the processing done by the hardware, and created software (that would only work on windows) to replicate that function. AGPS is similar, and while yes it will lock on faster, it loads off processing onto 3rd party providers (that could be the cell towers providing orbital data, or the cpu in the device itself to do the processing)...

It is a way of cutting the cost of the chipsets in addition to providing faster service, at the expense of a self contained unit, and carriers like this because even if you don't use the cell towers to get the info, you still using data (for example with the Tilt, I download the data every 6 days using software, and not from cell towers), so either way ATT (or any provider requires you to use data, unless you want to do it everytime you sync through the PC..... which people will always seem to forget..)



Posted by: T_Webb

Quote:
Originally Posted by KDarling
TomTom Navigator 6 for PDAs is around $150 on DVD. Yes, maps are locally stored. Less than 2GB, I think (could be wrong).

My big question is, does TomTom keep running even when a call comes in? Or does it exit as Apple wishes for most apps to do?


If they created the software for and running the software on a jailbroken device then Apples rules don't matter. If they're going to push the software through the App Store then I would think that the app would close out after pressing the home button.



Posted by: bonesb

Chiming in with mixed feelings here. Real GPS was one of my four "gimmes" for the iPhone, but I'm not sure TomTom is the company I'd buy from. I really like the new iPhone - even comes out on my b-day!

I own a GO 910, and the maps really aren't the best. Roads I worked on 8 years ago that were added or deleted or realigned still show up uncorrected in Teleatlas maps (I have the latest paid update).

I'm more pissed about TomTom's new mapping update pricing policy - mapping updates for their units for NA are now $99 a pop. Their company related they're going to be issuing updates quarterly. Yikes!

On another note, I also paid for their PLUS traffic service. Last winter, their servers went down for 6 weeks, right through the holidays. They didn't know why. They also didn't notify paid subscribers, even though the device login for PLUS service is an e-mail account name. No refund, just extended my service. Yeah, extending a service that doesn't work properly. Just what I wanted, another helping of something that doesn't work....

About the aGPS thing, for standalone software, it's not a bad thing. My TomTom gets regular sat fix updates via the HOME application or via my data connection. If I'm out of range of cell service, the lock just takes a minute or so longer.

I really hope Garmin creates a package for the iPhone. I'll see how far I can chuck my GO 910 then!



Posted by: jvanbrecht

In addition to TomTom, apparently Navigon has software for the iphone (legit for the 3g and jailbroken). It would be suicide from a business standpoint for Garmin and Magellan to not do the same. More so for Garmin, as their $600 priced nuvifone is about to become a useless overpriced paperweight... in the light of a $200 device that can do the same and more...



Posted by: remo74tg

I really hope TomTOM is available with real GPS. I've been in the limousine business for about ten years and tried different GPS units since they became available and I'd say without a doubt TomTom is the best.



Posted by: BoomerangToss

Quote:
Originally Posted by superlatives
Folks:

I would LOVE to see an iPhone version of Nokia Maps 2.0

Reason: Nokia Maps does something that no other (that I know of) navigation s/w does -- it gives you WALKING directions.

Here in Boston, Nokia Maps 2.0 even diagrams footpaths in Boston Common and the Public Garden. It also gives walking directions on streets which are one-way.



That's an interesting feature. Do you have to stare at a screen or does it talk to your earbud so you can keep your eyes on your surroundings?

"'Best Burgers' in 5 steps on your left across the street. Disorderly conduct in 10 steps on your right. You have arrived! Now GET DISORDERLY!"

Andy



Posted by: CingularWRX

I'll bet its got telenav



Posted by: RogerPodacter

Quote:
Originally Posted by remo74tg
I really hope TomTOM is available with real GPS. I've been in the limousine business for about ten years and tried different GPS units since they became available and I'd say without a doubt TomTom is the best.


it will absolutely be real GPS. it will work just as good as if you had a real tomtom in your car. same with the n95 and garmin, works flawlessly for me.



Posted by: RogerPodacter

Quote:
Originally Posted by BoomerangToss
That's an interesting feature. Do you have to stare at a screen or does it talk to your earbud so you can keep your eyes on your surroundings?

"'Best Burgers' in 5 steps on your left across the street. Disorderly conduct in 10 steps on your right. You have arrived! Now GET DISORDERLY!"

Andy


yeah nokia maps is alright, but garmin is better on my phone. the walking mode of nokia maps can certainly speak out loud or thru your headset while you walk. it also has satellite image mode similar to google maps, but it leaves a bread crumb trail behind you so you can see where you came from.



Posted by: superlatives

Quote:
Originally Posted by BoomerangToss
That's an interesting feature. Do you have to stare at a screen or does it talk to your earbud so you can keep your eyes on your surroundings?

"'Best Burgers' in 5 steps on your left across the street. Disorderly conduct in 10 steps on your right. You have arrived! Now GET DISORDERLY!"

Andy

Andy:

For WALKING, you have to stare at the screen.

In Nokia Maps 2.0, voice navigation is provided only for driving directions. Walking directions are plotted on map only (no voice). Still, the best part is that the "calculated route" in Nokia Maps takes into account "footpaths", rather than JUST sidewalks.

Here's a screen shot of a walking route through Boston Common:



The big red dot is where you are, the smaller ones are where you've been. And the dark grey line is the calculated route.



Posted by: BoomerangToss

Quote:
Originally Posted by remo74tg
I really hope TomTOM is available with real GPS. I've been in the limousine business for about ten years and tried different GPS units since they became available and I'd say without a doubt TomTom is the best.



My local tow truck fleet agrees. They found my house and only overshot by about 8 feet.

The new TT930 with IQ routing for speeds at times of days on different roads on different days based on user speeds rather than posted speed limits is quite a late & great technology.

I'd hope as the TomTom picture shows, the keyboard also orients itself that way. And it better speak up street names loud. The iPhone has a relatively quiet speaker.

The only other concern is if it will have a cable with a gps antenna for sky view and low dashboard mounting for better view in bright sunlight (Hertz: NeverLost [magellan]). The TomTom hardware also has the FM broadcast transmitter to several FM radio frequencies to sound off on the car radio. If it can't do that on the 3G iPhone, it's going to be disappointing just as software only.

Andy



Posted by: superlatives

Quote:
Originally Posted by RogerPodacter
yeah nokia maps is alright, but garmin is better on my phone. the walking mode of nokia maps can certainly speak out loud or thru your headset while you walk. it also has satellite image mode similar to google maps, but it leaves a bread crumb trail behind you so you can see where you came from.

Roger:

HOW do you get voice navigation on walking routes? I've NEVER been able to do that.

And does Garmin do walking routes? IF SO ... that would be a GREAT piece of software for the iPhone 3G. Assuming it can use Bluetooth GPS.



Posted by: BoomerangToss

Quote:
Originally Posted by superlatives
Andy:

For WALKING, you have to stare at the screen.

In Nokia Maps 2.0, voice navigation is provided only for driving directions. Walking directions are plotted on map only (no voice). Still, the best part is that the "calculated route" in Nokia Maps takes into account "footpaths", rather than JUST sidewalks.

Here's a screen shot of a walking route through Boston Common:



The big red dot is where you are, the smaller ones are where you've been. And the dark grey line is the calculated route.



I at all times, keep my eyes on my surroundings. Have you ever been held up at gunpoint by a junkie in a parking lot at night in the rain?

Taking your eyes off your surroundings is a very bad idea.

Bad guys love people who aren't looking out for trouble.

I learned my lesson!

Best,

Andy
007.5 (self defense)



Posted by: RogerPodacter

Why would you stare at your phone screen all the time? I think a quick glance down at the screen like a normal human being is how most people use it lol. Some of the thinking in this forum lol...



Posted by: f1restarter

There is a comparison between the latest Tom Tom (930) and the Nuvi 780 I believe where Tom Tom was off the mark by about 2 city blocks and the Nuvi was dead on. Most reviewers say that while Tom Tom is best for europe, it isn't that accurate in the USA, especially when compared to the Nuvi.



Posted by: superlatives

Quote:
Originally Posted by RogerPodacter
Why would you stare at your phone screen all the time? I think a quick glance down at the screen like a normal human being is how most people use it lol. Some of the thinking in this forum lol...

Roger:

I have to admit that, until recently, I would stare at the screen, just to see the little red trailing dots follow me! THAT novelty is over!

And when using Sports Tracker, I still do stare at the track to make sure I still have a nine-satellite lock!



Posted by: superlatives

Quote:
Originally Posted by f1restarter
There is a comparison between the latest Tom Tom (930) and the Nuvi 780 I believe where Tom Tom was off the mark by about 2 city blocks and the Nuvi was dead on. Most reviewers say that while Tom Tom is best for europe, it isn't that accurate in the USA, especially when compared to the Nuvi.

F1:

Did the review comment about the satellite lock status of both systems (did each have the same number of satellites locked to the receiver)?

Also remember that accuracy is based upon the chip used. The Broadcom chip which will be used in the iPhone 3G will NEVER be as accurate -- even with network assist -- as a handset with the SIRFStar II or MTK chip.



Posted by: CA

Quote:
Originally Posted by jvanbrecht
TomTom pricing is $99 for the software only option, same as the Garmin software only option. That does not include the cost of the monthly service if you want traffic updates and other services.
I've been gone all day so if the iPhone can now use Garmin XT mobile it's news to me.

But both CoPilot and Garmin(both WM apps) use phone data....and the feeds(weather traffic motel.com etc.) are free. Tom tom makes you pay for them!



Posted by: CA

Quote:
Originally Posted by RogerPodacter
Why would you stare at your phone screen all the time? I think a quick glance down at the screen like a normal human being is how most people use it lol. Some of the thinking in this forum lol...
J/K, but you need to stare because of all the glare, even dialing in the sun is a pita.



Posted by: f1restarter

Quote:
Originally Posted by superlatives
F1:

Did the review comment about the satellite lock status of both systems (did each have the same number of satellites locked to the receiver)?

Also remember that accuracy is based upon the chip used. The Broadcom chip which will be used in the iPhone 3G will NEVER be as accurate -- even with network assist -- as a handset with the SIRFStar II or MTK chip.


Here is the link to what I was talking about earlier: http://gpstracklog.typepad.com/gps_...m-go-930-v.html



Posted by: KDarling

Quote:
Originally Posted by jvanbrecht
AGPS is not really a step forward...


I used to think that. We're wrong. A-GPS isn't much different than using WAAS or any other GPS assistance.

It makes perfect sense to ask a local server for satellite and interference information. Even makes sense to ask the server to do the calculations, as long as the phone can also do it all standalone if need be.

As you said, A-GPS a way of cutting cost. But it makes sense to do so, and to have a solution that fits inside a phone that also has so many other radios and antennae (wifi, bluetooth, 3g, FM in some cases).

Cheers, Kev



Posted by: BoomerangToss

So will the iPhone be able to do instant re-routing after missing an exit or turn?

I don't see it.

I'll be happier with a separate GPS.

Maybe the Nuvi. I'll read some reviews.

I have the DeLorme earthmate GPS but it got old having to drag the laptop to use it.

iPhone users who don't know true GPS navigation, it's 90% voice/sounds and 10% view, imho.

iPhone GPS is 100% view from what I've witnessed. I was spoiled by Hertz's NeverLost, which didn't have a dozen menus to fish through to get GPS'd on your way. I've road tripped several times in a Hertz rental and was NeverLost.

You want pizza, whip out the iPhone and google-map them, then leave the GPS navigation to the pros, imho.

Andy



Posted by: CA

Not trying to be a thread crapper, but if you look into the Android-Gphone coming out at the end of the year it does have heading up with recalculation of routes!

My guess is that Gmaps wasn't designed(Google sells advertising) to be used as a personal navigation device(PND) and that's what at&t is using. But in the case of Android the developers use the Gmap feeds to create a PND experience.

Just go to the "Dash" web site and see what they did to Yahoo maps!



Posted by: CA

Now if this happens!
Quote:
There are also other rumors that has the Dash navigation software loaded onto the iPhone too, which would put a very connected experience into the hands of iPhone users. The advanced traffic capabilities would be a plus.
Huge difference!

http://www.gpslodge.com/archives/019483.php



Posted by: KDarling

Quote:
Originally Posted by BoomerangToss
So will the iPhone be able to do instant re-routing after missing an exit or turn? I don't see it.


Or voice directions or points of interest. Although someone could write a mashup kind of app that used various servers to simulate some of this.

Quote:
I'll be happier with a separate GPS.


For driving, that seems to make sense in this case, and here's two reasons why:

1) Major phone navigation apps costs $100-150. For that, you can get a standalone GPS that has the antenna and radio channels to give solid performance.

2) The iPhone doesn't allow tasks to continue when you get a call. On some other phones, you can answer the call or see an incoming text, but continue to get driving directions as well. That is what a convergent device should do.

But on the iPhone, which is less convergent / multitasking and more like a basket of separate apps, you'd have to reach up and click the Home button and restart the navigation app during the call. At least, the way things are set up now. Hopefully Apple can make (yet another) exception for this.



Posted by: BoomerangToss

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sonix
Now if this happens!
Huge difference!

http://www.gpslodge.com/archives/019483.php



Hey, but...

I saw the traffic red/yellow/green on the 1st gen iPhone. How is it to be trusted? How is it reported in real time?

Which begs the question will it alert and re-route you around a traffic issue in time?

I have a scanner and hear the TV traffic helo's which saved me a handful of times.

Andy



Posted by: flyingdutchman

I honestly would never use any phone GPS for turn by turn directions. Phones cannot compete with the likes of the Dash.



Posted by: BoomerangToss

Quote:
Originally Posted by flyingdutchman
I honestly would never use any phone GPS for turn by turn directions. Phones cannot compete with the likes of the Dash.


OK, Dash?

Again, I'll look them up.

Andy



Posted by: samab

Quote:
Originally Posted by flyingdutchman
I honestly would never use any phone GPS for turn by turn directions. Phones cannot compete with the likes of the Dash.


The carriers compete because they provide the type of service on a free phone cheaper --- and they get the same maps as everybody else.



Posted by: orimental

Add this to TomTom GPS on the iPhone and I think we've got a winner.



Posted by: jvanbrecht

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sonix
I've been gone all day so if the iPhone can now use Garmin XT mobile it's news to me.

But both CoPilot and Garmin(both WM apps) use phone data....and the feeds(weather traffic motel.com etc.) are free. Tom tom makes you pay for them!


I did not say it will use XT, I was responding on the original poster stating a $150 price range.

However, Garmin is in a slight bind.. they have the nuvifone coming out, which won't be cheap ($600 was the last rumour and about the cost of an avg non subsidized phone). But the iphone will have much greater consumer uptake then any phone that garmin releases (hell no one outside the geek community even knows about it, but everyone knows about the iphone), so for Garmin not to release a product for the iphone, will be suicide on their part (atleast amongst the competing software only applications)



Posted by: jvanbrecht

Quote:
Originally Posted by flyingdutchman
I honestly would never use any phone GPS for turn by turn directions. Phones cannot compete with the likes of the Dash.


The problem with the dash is that for it to be of any real use (atleast from a traffic aspect), there needs to be a relatively decent sized community of dash users, otherwise you just have another GPS device that may actually have inaccurate data and a monthly subscription. Its a great premise, but until there is wider adoption, its not worth it.



Posted by: nicktuso

I would buy a gps application for my current phone if i could do so. I don't know how that would or would not work.



Posted by: superlatives

Quote:
Originally Posted by nicktuso
I would buy a gps application for my current phone if i could do so. I don't know how that would or would not work.

Right now, it wouldn't work.

However ... IF Apple's 2.0 firmware includes support for the Serial Port Profile of Bluetooth 2.0, and IF you can "buy" or get free Google Maps, then you COULD spend $60 on an external Bluetooth GPS receiver. Size of a Bic lighter.

I did, even though the Nokia N95 has internal A-GPS, and am very happy. Internal A-GPS chips will never be as accurate or as fast as an external receiver.



Posted by: BoomerangToss

Quote:
Originally Posted by superlatives
Right now, it wouldn't work.

However ... IF Apple's 2.0 firmware includes support for the Serial Port Profile of Bluetooth 2.0, and IF you can "buy" or get free Google Maps, then you COULD spend $60 on an external Bluetooth GPS receiver. Size of a Bic lighter.

I did, even though the Nokia N95 has internal A-GPS, and am very happy. Internal A-GPS chips will never be as accurate or as fast as an external receiver.




Google isn''t the end all, be all when it comes to GPS. They are a late player to the game.

Google Earth, I give them credit for that.

But you have to have freedom of choice. Google will slowly fade away, imho.

Andy



Posted by: superlatives

Quote:
Originally Posted by BoomerangToss
Google isn''t the end all, be all when it comes to GPS. They are a late player to the game.

Google Earth, I give them credit for that.

But you have to have freedom of choice. Google will slowly fade away, imho.

Andy

Andy:

Sorry ... didn't mean to "praise" Google Maps. I mentioned it only because it WILL be available for iPhone. Personally my favorite is Nokia Maps.

However, IF firmware 2.0 implements SPP, then Tomtom WOULD work, since external BT GPS is already part of their code.



Posted by: CA

Quote:
Originally Posted by jvanbrecht
I did not say it will use XT, I was responding on the original poster stating a $150 price range.

However, Garmin is in a slight bind.. they have the nuvifone coming out, which won't be cheap ($600 was the last rumour and about the cost of an avg non subsidized phone). But the iphone will have much greater consumer uptake then any phone that garmin releases (hell no one outside the geek community even knows about it, but everyone knows about the iphone), so for Garmin not to release a product for the iphone, will be suicide on their part (atleast amongst the competing software only applications)
I don't know if anyone has caught this yet:

Quote:
Apple's always been known for its amusingly-conservative disclaimers (you can't use iTunes to "design a nuclear weapon," for example) and it looks like the products-liability team at the Fruit has had their way with the iPhone SDK agreement as well, inserting a provision specifically prohibiting developers from creating apps "marketed for real time route guidance; automatic or autonomous control of vehicles, aircraft, or other mechanical devices; dispatch or fleet management; or emergency or life-saving purposes." Yep, that's right -- no real-time route guidance (or, uh, fleet management) allowed. That'd be a huge bummer -- except, of course, that TomTom has already come out and said that its app is ready to go on the iPhone. Assuming TomTom used the SDK and not the jailbreak toolchain, we'd bet that Apple is just covering its *** here and that it's worked out an agreement with TomTom to pass along any liability -- you can bet Steve doesn't want to get sued when iPhone users start careening into sandpiles and into oncoming trains. We'll see for sure when the App Store finally launches, though -- until then, it's all just cheap speculation.

Update: Astute commenter Austin points out that these terms are copied almost word-for-word from the Google Maps API terms -- which means that TomTom and others are probably free to use their own maps to do real-time guidance
http://www.engadget.com/2008/06/11/...idance-dancing/



Posted by: superlatives

Sonix:

Yes I saw that ... and the only way to find out is if we see TomTom or Garmin XT on the App Store.

FYI it may have nothing to do with the API itself -- Apple may be scared about getting sued over the GPS chip which THEY decided to use. Remember that internal handset A-GPS chips are FAR from reliable.



Posted by: yipperzz

Quote:
Originally Posted by BoomerangToss
Google isn''t the end all, be all when it comes to GPS. They are a late player to the game.

Google Earth, I give them credit for that.

But you have to have freedom of choice. Google will slowly fade away, imho.

Andy


You should give credit to Keyhole then. Google didn't create Google Earth.



Posted by: jvanbrecht

That whole real time guidance thing has already been explained, it its most likely not related to a user using it for navigation, but rather integrating the gps/guidance application in something that will use that info for autonomous use... like say autopilot on boats and planes... Thats my take on it anyways.



Posted by: CA

Quote:
Originally Posted by jvanbrecht
That whole real time guidance thing has already been explained, it its most likely not related to a user using it for navigation, but rather integrating the gps/guidance application in something that will use that info for autonomous use... like say autopilot on boats and planes... Thats my take on it anyways.
IMO, I think it means that you(or anyone but Apple) can't develop a nav app using the API.

Google does it, you can't develop or use their gmaps behind a logon.



Posted by: superlatives

Quote:
Originally Posted by jvanbrecht
That whole real time guidance thing has already been explained, it its most likely not related to a user using it for navigation, but rather integrating the gps/guidance application in something that will use that info for autonomous use... like say autopilot on boats and planes... Thats my take on it anyways.

I agree Ivan ...

... here's a link to sportstracker.nokia.com from one of my walks. Although my GPS receiver had a 10-satellite lock, my Bluetooth flaked out for about 1/2 mile, right before I got to the bridge.

http://sportstracker.nokia.com/nts/...ex.do?id=225680

Imagine if I used this for a car autopilot system on the iPhone 3G! The next thread would be "How do I dry out my iPhone, to say nothing about my car?"

:-)



Posted by: nicktuso

This thread has good info. Great reading.



Posted by: BoomerangToss

Quote:
Originally Posted by nicktuso
I would buy a gps application for my current phone if i could do so. I don't know how that would or would not work.



Pretty much, if you're not a road-hauler or don't travel outside of your 10-mile radius world, or offer pizza delivery, GPS is pretty useless.

For the 8,000 mile road trip or your in a new city, it's extremely useful. How often? I dunno.

As the price of gas rises, GPS shortcuts would be beneficial, except like AAA who trip tix (no GPS about it) routes you past paid advertisers which Google maps probably does too.

'Nuf said.

Andy



Posted by: nicktuso

Quote:
Originally Posted by BoomerangToss
Pretty much, if you're not a road-hauler or don't travel outside of your 10-mile radius world, or offer pizza delivery, GPS is pretty useless.

For the 8,000 mile road trip or your in a new city, it's extremely useful. How often? I dunno.

As the price of gas rises, GPS shortcuts would be beneficial, except like AAA who trip tix (no GPS about it) routes you past paid advertisers which Google maps probably does too.

'Nuf said.

Andy



I would never use the actual gps...my google maps right now on 1.1.4 is amazing. It finds me and routes me to where I need to go quickly all over edge. I have never had a problem using it and never gotten lost using it. I agree with you 100%



Posted by: BoomerangToss

Quote:
Originally Posted by nicktuso
I would never use the actual gps...my google maps right now on 1.1.4 is amazing. It finds me and routes me to where I need to go quickly all over edge. I have never had a problem using it and never gotten lost using it. I agree with you 100%


I've seen iPhone gps demonstrated skillfully but it's all see, no speak! No auto-rerouting.

It just locates the iPhone and plots a destination route from there using google mapping. Dumb GPS.

You should rent a Hertz rent-a-car with NeverLost, then get back to me on ease of use. I think the newer dedicated GPS navigation systems are probably even better.

The 3G iPhone doesn't introduce better GPS. I could be mistaken, haven't seen it in operation.

The other problem is now we'll need a dash mount and questionable bright sunlight viewability. It MUST speak otherwise it's a dangerous hazard. External GPS antenna make for better out-of-sun mounting of a GPS unit.

I'ts a phone and ipod and internet connection.

They can't get everything right. We've seen that in Apple software and hardware time and time again.

Steve-O is just a great carnival showman. "LADIES AND GENTLEMEN..."

'Gain, 'nuf said.

Andy



Posted by: jvanbrecht

Quote:
Originally Posted by BoomerangToss
Pretty much, if you're not a road-hauler or don't travel outside of your 10-mile radius world, or offer pizza delivery, GPS is pretty useless.

For the 8,000 mile road trip or your in a new city, it's extremely useful. How often? I dunno.

As the price of gas rises, GPS shortcuts would be beneficial, except like AAA who trip tix (no GPS about it) routes you past paid advertisers which Google maps probably does too.

'Nuf said.

Andy


I disagree, it may not be as much use in more rural areas, but use DC for example, where I drive daily, with constant construction, constant traffic (you can get into a 5 mile backup at 3am in the morning on 495 or 95 without too much trouble), it becomes extremely useful, especially when you take into account some of the premium services offered (or in some cases like Garmin, free when you buy the software), where it will pull down weather and traffic patterns, and router you around those appropriately and in real time while you are driving.



Posted by: BoomerangToss

Quote:
Originally Posted by jvanbrecht
I disagree, it may not be as much use in more rural areas, but use DC for example, where I drive daily, with constant construction, constant traffic (you can get into a 5 mile backup at 3am in the morning on 495 or 95 without too much trouble), it becomes extremely useful, especially when you take into account some of the premium services offered (or in some cases like Garmin, free when you buy the software), where it will pull down weather and traffic patterns, and router you around those appropriately and in real time while you are driving.



Not knocking GPS at all, just the iPhone is NOT true GPS navigation compared to the pros in the biz.

Andy



Posted by: jvanbrecht

Quote:
Originally Posted by BoomerangToss
Not knocking GPS at all, just the iPhone is NOT true GPS navigation compared to the pros in the biz.

Andy


Depends on how you look at it. a GPS chipset is just that, a piece of hardware that gets a bunch of numbers and has no idea what to do with them.

It is how you implement those numbers, and that is where the applications come in. It really has nothing to do with the physical hardware housing the GPS chipset (other then needing good processing power to actually notify a user of turns before he passes them... and things like that).

So technically, if the right application is used on the iphone, it could absolutely destroy any PND out there (excluding PC's and laptops and specialized equipment like say military GPS units and Autopilots etc).

But for a PND, implemented correctly, it could be a fantastic device.



Posted by: BoomerangToss

Quote:
Originally Posted by jvanbrecht
But for a PND, implemented correctly, it could be a fantastic device.


The iPhone would have to have onboard maps and talk and ding to make it true GPS navigation. Not fetch from Google maps.

Still, GPS is minor feature that may become useful once in awhile, on vacation somewhere, on a great cell phone!

Andy



Posted by: yipperzz

Quote:
Originally Posted by BoomerangToss
The iPhone would have to have onboard maps and talk and ding to make it true GPS navigation. Not fetch from Google maps.

Still, GPS is minor feature that may become useful once in awhile, on vacation somewhere, on a great cell phone!

Andy


That is why people are excited about a TomTom or TeleNav app for the iphone.



Posted by: nicktuso

Quote:
Originally Posted by BoomerangToss
I've seen iPhone gps demonstrated skillfully but it's all see, no speak! No auto-rerouting.

It just locates the iPhone and plots a destination route from there using google mapping. Dumb GPS.

You should rent a Hertz rent-a-car with NeverLost, then get back to me on ease of use. I think the newer dedicated GPS navigation systems are probably even better.

The 3G iPhone doesn't introduce better GPS. I could be mistaken, haven't seen it in operation.

The other problem is now we'll need a dash mount and questionable bright sunlight viewability. It MUST speak otherwise it's a dangerous hazard. External GPS antenna make for better out-of-sun mounting of a GPS unit.

I'ts a phone and ipod and internet connection.

They can't get everything right. We've seen that in Apple software and hardware time and time again.

Steve-O is just a great carnival showman. "LADIES AND GENTLEMEN..."

'Gain, 'nuf said.

Andy




I have the Bracketron mount for my front window and it swivels so I can has music video/movie watching in the car. I love the mount and still love my first gen iPhone enough to keep it for another 6 months till everything is worked out for tmo if ever.



Posted by: jestexman

Guys i have a moto rokr with alltel and evdo. It has a nav app that does turn by turn directions with voice. Im thinking that anything that they use for the new iphone is going to be real close to a real nav system.

Then one for my alltel phone is close to by buds tom tom. (not real close but i was supprised)



Posted by: harlenm

And ATT is advertising a new Blackberry with a turn by turn GPS system.

Sorry, best one I could find on youtube.
http://youtube.com/watch?v=xq7pDn0_...feature=related



Posted by: THETRUTH#34

my n95 is awesome with the gps, i had it next to my friends tom tom stand alone and it worked just as well, recalculates and everything. here is a little video and this has nothing to do with a nokia phone just about real gpds built into the phone and how well it works.
http://technorati.com/videos/youtub...v%3D3UiZuRzTIl4
http://s52.photobucket.com/albums/g...nt=DSCN5184.flv
http://s52.photobucket.com/albums/g...nt=DSCN5185.flv
http://s52.photobucket.com/albums/g...nt=DSCN5188.flv
Sorry Roger just need them to see, i know its your info.



Posted by: CA

Quote:
Originally Posted by THETRUTH#34
my n95 is awesome with the gps, i had it next to my friends tom tom stand alone and it worked just as well, recalculates and everything. here is a little video and this has nothing to do with a nokia phone just about real gpds built into the phone and how well it works.
http://technorati.com/videos/youtub...v%3D3UiZuRzTIl4
http://s52.photobucket.com/albums/g...nt=DSCN5184.flv
http://s52.photobucket.com/albums/g...nt=DSCN5185.flv
http://s52.photobucket.com/albums/g...nt=DSCN5188.flv
Sorry Roger just need them to see, i know its your info.

Interesting videos! I'm still waiting to buy the Garmin XT mobile for my Touch(Sprint) because the new ROM upgrade turns GPS on and Garmin told me that you can't use a puck with XT. Is that true? If you get a chance can you check the GPS setup, with MapQuest Navigator device GPS is default but you can chose either external BT or serial.

And secondly is the GPS in the Nokia aGPS, if so that explains the speed on a cloudy day. I do have a few Garmins and the newer ones get an initial fix in ~20sec, unless you don't use them for a few days(the sat info gets stale)



Posted by: RogerPodacter

yes the nokia in my videos there uses aGPS. i forgot those videos...



Posted by: THETRUTH#34

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sonix
Interesting videos! I'm still waiting to buy the Garmin XT mobile for my Touch(Sprint) because the new ROM upgrade turns GPS on and Garmin told me that you can't use a puck with XT. Is that true? If you get a chance can you check the GPS setup, with MapQuest Navigator device GPS is default but you can chose either external BT or serial.

And secondly is the GPS in the Nokia aGPS, if so that explains the speed on a cloudy day. I do have a few Garmins and the newer ones get an initial fix in ~20sec, unless you don't use them for a few days(the sat info gets stale)
my connection on cloudy and rainy days have been 20 seconds and under with the agps that is.



Posted by: CA

Ok, It's been a buisy few days for me so please humor me. Whoever has the Garmin XT mobile app can you check on it being able to use an external GPS puck? Garmin gives you a 30 trial and I would like to see if it meets my needs in other areas. I plan on using their API to code a two way "presence" with my server. I'm told that it can be done, but people that have done it use the older 10 version witch comes with their puck. I want to run without.

Two things impress me about the XT app:

1. Free Free Free traffic and other services!

2. From those videos you can start a route without a traffic D/L, hopefully you can do if after you start the route.



Posted by: BoomerangToss

Quote:
Originally Posted by nicktuso

I have the Bracketron mount for my front window and it swivels so I can has music video/movie watching in the car. I love the mount and still love my first gen iPhone enough to keep it for another 6 months till everything is worked out for tmo if ever.



How ugly is that!

What happens when the phone rings and the GPS loses sky?

Andy



Posted by: CA

Quote:
Originally Posted by BoomerangToss
How ugly is that!

What happens when the phone rings and the GPS loses sky?

Andy
The phone rings and you lose sky!



Posted by: jvanbrecht

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sonix
The phone rings and you lose sky!


No, if that happens precisely at the same time... the space time continuum splits and all the alternate universes collide...

or so I heard

As for the puck thing, I am pretty sure you should be able to.. I went looking for the 30 day trial on garmins site.. no luck the only options I see are buy and learn more, and I have spent a good hour or 2 looking around. I have an older htc wizard that I used to use my Pharos bt gps with, and it worked fine with the TomTom. It is really just setting the com port (whatever serial port you assigned the BT GPS unit or physical unit)



Posted by: CA

Quote:
Originally Posted by jvanbrecht
No, if that happens precisely at the same time... the space time continuum splits and all the alternate universes collide...

or so I heard

As for the puck thing, I am pretty sure you should be able to.. I went looking for the 30 day trial on garmins site.. no luck the only options I see are buy and learn more, and I have spent a good hour or 2 looking around. I have an older htc wizard that I used to use my Pharos bt gps with, and it worked fine with the TomTom. It is really just setting the com port (whatever serial port you assigned the BT GPS unit or physical unit)
Call Garmin dummy! I think they hide it to keep people like me away!

CoPilot used to only work with their plug in plucks, no options. And they have a 30 day too. But you'll find like I did they use their own maps in the US and they don't compare to TeleAtlas or Navteq!



Posted by: jvanbrecht

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sonix
CoPilot used to only work with their plug in plucks, no options. And they have a 30 day too. But you'll find like I did they use their own maps in the US and they don't compare to TeleAtlas or Navteq!


So far I have had good luck with the garmin products I have used, that I actually paid for (I do trial things before I buy... one way or another). The wife has a Forerunner 305 (the gps runners watch), and while it is huge, it works extremely well... If only they would get the damn 405 out (been delayed half a dozen times).

For street maps, I have never really had luck with anyone, especially in the DC area where the roads today, or gone tomorrow and under construction...

As for topo maps, Garmin make some good maps, but no one beats out the National Geographic topo maps (which work on the garmins that support topo maps, which supposedly the XT supports...

I will have to call them. My end goal, regardless of which product I get, is to make sure that the maps work on everything, I do not want to spend 150 a dvd for maps for different devices, and while I do carry my old phone with me when I mountain bike, I would prefer something a little more robust... So once the iphone is out, I will make sure whatever I get, the maps work on the software version and the hardware device I get (maybe one of the colorodo units)



Posted by: RogerPodacter

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sonix
Ok, It's been a buisy few days for me so please humor me. Whoever has the Garmin XT mobile app can you check on it being able to use an external GPS puck? Garmin gives you a 30 trial and I would like to see if it meets my needs in other areas. I plan on using their API to code a two way "presence" with my server. I'm told that it can be done, but people that have done it use the older 10 version witch comes with their puck. I want to run without.

Two things impress me about the XT app:

1. Free Free Free traffic and other services!

2. From those videos you can start a route without a traffic D/L, hopefully you can do if after you start the route.


YES garmin allows you to pair an external bluetooth GPS puck no problem...



Posted by: CA

Quote:
Originally Posted by RogerPodacter
YES garmin allows you to pair an external bluetooth GPS puck no problem...

Thanks, I guess I was listening to the rep too much, he said yes with the 10 version(I think that's what it was called), but no with the XT.

I'll find out soon enough, I'm hitting Visa as we speak!





vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Limited.
vB Easy Archive Final ©2000 - 2008 - Created by Stefan "Xenon" Kaeser