vB Easy Archive - New p900 review: Stuff Mag UK Jan 04

Pages: 1

New p900 review: Stuff Mag UK Jan 04
(Click here to view the original thread with full colors/images)

Posted by: jmburt

Unfortunately, the review is not available online. The new January 2004 issue (100 Greatest Gadgets issue) of Stuff Magazine (UK) has a brief review of the new p900. (page 12)

The p900 also grabs the #2 spot in the Top 100 gadgets of 2003.(right behind the #1 Apple Ipod 3G)

...and the #1 spot in the 10 Ten Smartphone category (un-seating the previous #1, the Motorola MPx200 smartphone)

Check it out at a newstand near you!

Posted by: lgreenberg

Do you happen to have the entire list of top ten smartphones? I'd be curious to see the whole thing.

Posted by: jmburt

Quote:

Originally posted by lgreenberg
Do you happen to have the entire list of top ten smartphones? I'd be curious to see the whole thing.

sten

Here is the top 10 (as of January 2004) with ratings (5 stars the best):

1. Sony Ericsson p900 (*****)
2. Motorola Mpx200 (*****)
3. Orange Spv E200 (****)
4. O2 XDA II (****)
5. Sony Ericsson p800 (****)
6. Treo 600 (****)
7. Nokia 3650 (****)
8. Motorola A920 (***)
9. Palm Tungsten W (***)
10 Nokia 7650(***)

Kind of crazy that the p800 still is in the top 5 when the technology is over a year old. Proves again, that SE was ahead of its time....

Here is the list of handsets/smartphones/phone accessories that made the Top 100 gadgets of 2003:

#2 Sony Ericsson p900
#15 Blackberry 7320
#17 Orange SPV E200
#19 Sony Ericsson T630
#23 Motorola A835
#38 O2 XDA II
#39 Sony Ericsson HBM (bluetooth MP3 player)
#44 Nokia N-Gage (i don't know how this banana phone made the top 100)
#48 Siemens SL55
#57 Sharp GX20
#68 Siemens SX1
#69 Sony Ericsson CAR-100 (bluetooth car)
#87 Motorola MPx200

Posted by: sdsviet

ngage only made cuz it was a very hyped up gadget. a gadget doesnt mean it had to be good. i wonder if the segway is on there.

Posted by: jmburt

Quote:

Originally posted by sdsviet
ngage only made cuz it was a very hyped up gadget. a gadget doesnt mean it had to be good. i wonder if the segway is on there.

the segway wasn't in the top 100.....go figure...

Posted by: mavericke

What a pity as the A920 did not make it to top 5.

Posted by: sdsviet

i think the a920 didnt make it cuz it was not release doing the time of the review. there are a lot of better phones that were not release of the time of the review so they did not make it in there. can u list the top one hundred gadgets on there jmburt. i checked everywhere but there is no stuff gadget mag around my area. i can only get t3 for now. by the way t3 is amazing.

Posted by: The Rex

got the mag too (based on 3vw's earlier thread)... nice, but really fluffy