I'm looking for a phone for my mother in law. she currently has an old flip phone and wants to upgrade to something with a bigger screen that's simple to use. she got the pantech hotshot against my advice. not surprisingly, she hated it.

HTC Trophy notables

windows phone
Simple layout
very nice screen (better than the rhyme)
simple to use after initial set up
Buttery smooth interface
intuitive and pretty easy to learn

HTC Rhyme notables

charging dock
sense UI is excellent and covers up android pretty well
Very good battery life
Above average camera (current phone is 2mp)
Nice color (plum)

I'm leaning towards the trophy because the screen is nicer and because windows is very simple once set up..
but! The rhyme has a charging dock and a nice camera and battery life

anyone have a good reason to go with one over the other??